Litigating Reproductive Health Rights in the Inter-American System: What Does a Winning Case Look Like?
Item Type:Journal Article
Citation:O'Connell, C., Litigating Reproductive Health Rights in the Inter-American System: What Does a Winning Case Look Like?, Health and Human Rights, 14, 2, 2014, 116 - 128
O'Connell HHR.pdf (PDF) 1007.Kb
Remedies and reparation measures emerging from the Inter-American System of Human Rights in reproductive health cases have consistently highlighted the need to develop, and subsequently implement, non-repetition remedies that protect, promote, and fulfill women’s reproductive health rights. Litigation outcomes that determine there have been violations of reproductive rights are regarded as a “win” for health rights litigation, but when implementation fails, is a “win” still a win? There has been considerable success in litigating reproductive health rights cases, yet the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights are not adequately equipped to follow up on cases after they have been won. Successful and sustainable implementation of reproductive health rights law requires incorporation of non-repetition remedies in the form of legislation, education, and training that seeks to remodel existing social and cultural practices that hinder women’s enjoyment of their reproductive rights. In order for a reproductive health rights case to ultimately be a “winner,” case recommendations and decisions emerging from the Commission and Court must incorporate perspectives from members of civil society, with the ultimate goal being to develop measurable remedies that address underlying obstacles to domestic implementation.
Author: O'Connell, Ciara
Type of material:Journal Article
Series/Report no:Health and Human Rights;
Availability:Full text available
Subject (TCD):Inclusive Society , Gender Equality , Global Health , Reproductive health , WOMEN'S HEALTH
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
An audit of Irish mental health law for compliance with international human rights norms in respect of seven categories of 'mental health rights claims' : positive and negative findings, and recommendations for reform Quirke, Edel Thérèse (Trinity College (Dublin, Ireland). School of Law, 2011)This thesis subjects the legal regulation of the civil mental health law regime in Ireland to a ‘human rights audit’ subsequent to the implementation of the Mental Health Act 2001 (MHA 2001). The following structure is ...
PINHEIRO WALLA, ALICE (2014)This paper explores the alleged role of a conception of human nature for Kant’s justification of the duty to leave the state of nature and the related right to coerce others to enter the civil condition ...
Hayes, Noirin (Trinity College Dublin, 2002)Children?s Rights - Whose Right? A Review of Child Policy Development in Ireland reviews the position of children in contemporary Irish society and their emergence as a group inpolicy-making. Thestudy finds that a reactive, ...