Cubic Icosahedra? A Problem in Assigning Symmetry
LLOYD, DAVID ROBERT
Metadata:Show full item record
Citation:D. R. Lloyd, Cubic Icosahedra? A Problem in Assigning Symmetry,Journal of Chemical Education 2010 87 (8), 823-826
There is a standard convention that the icosahedral groups are classified separately from the cubic groups, but these two symmetry types have been conflated as ?cubic? in some chemistry textbooks. In this note, the connection between cubic and icosahedral symmetries is examined, using a simple pictorial model. It is shown that octahedral and icosahedral groups have a tetrahedral subgroup in common; in the full groups, this is the group Th, or, using just the rotation groups, the group T. In the analysis, various points emerge that may be of wider use in the teaching of symmetry. The misassignment of icosahedral symmetry as ?cubic? is traced to a significant article in virology, whose authority has been great enough to allow the error to spread widely, and the nature of this mistake is analyzed. Reasons to maintain the conventional separation of cubic and icosahedral groups are given.
Publisher:American Chemical Society
Series/Report no:Journal of Chemical Education;87, 8