Reconceptualising the First African Women's Protocol Case to Work for All Women
Item Type:Journal Article
Citation:C O’Connell ‘Reconceptualising the first African Women’s Protocol case to work for all women’ (2019) 19 African Human Rights Law Journal 510-533
Chapter Recent develop connelli 1_2019.pdf (PDF) 160.3Kb
The ECOWAS Court of Justice is the first human rights body to find a violation of the African region’s women’s rights treaty, the African Women’s Protocol. Nearly 15 years after the adoption of this Protocol, the ECOWAS Court determined in Dorothy Njemanze & 3 Others v Nigeria that the Nigerian state violated the rights of women because state agents assumed they were sex workers and, therefore, discriminated against them and treated them violently. Significantly, the Court determined that the state violated the women’s rights to dignity, as well as their right not to be arbitrarily detained and arrested. However, a feminist analysis of this case reveals that the ECOWAS Court’s judgment protected women who are not sex workers at the expense of sex workers’ rights. This article critically examines how the ECOWAS Court developed its jurisdiction in this case, with a particular focus on how the Court’s strategic avoidance of the topic of sex work resulted in a judgment that is harmful to sex workers. The article reconceptualises the Court’s reasoning to provide alternative approaches for interpreting women’s rights, especially sex workers’ rights. By providing the ECOWAS Court judgment with an alternative approach, which includes an analysis of the right to work and the right to dignity, through the application of the African Women’s Protocol and other human rights instruments, the article provides a feminist and inclusive perspective on how women’s rights could be approached in future judgments and litigation efforts
Author: O'Connell, Ciara
Type of material:Journal Article
Series/Report no:African Human Rights Law Journal;
Availability:Full text available
Keywords:Women’s rights, Sex work, Economic Community of West African States, African Women’s Protocol
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Adams, KeadiInformation and communication technologies have transformed the transport sector over the past few decades. The expansion of technology into every part of daily life has left some groups disadvantaged, creating barriers ...
Anglo-Irish and Gaelic women in Ireland c. 1277-1534 : a study of the conditions and rights of single women, wives, widows and nuns in late medieval Ireland Kenny, Gillian (Trinity College (Dublin, Ireland). Department of History, 2005)This thesis is a study of how women's legal, economic, social and political rights were profoundly affected by their marital state. The aim is firstly to provide a coherent picture of the lives of women in medieval Ireland ...
Australian, Irish and Swedish women?s perceptions of what assisted them to breastfeed for six months: exploratory design using critical incident technique Gallagher, Louise; Gallagher, Louise (2016)